PDA

View Full Version : Is Astronomy and Astrology the Same?


ramsatya
December 12, 2008, 03:35 PM
Astrology

Astrology is in short a superstition that originated in Babylon around 1000BC. Having a look at the movement of the planets the ancients believed that the position of the planets during your birth determined your life. Though there are more complicated permutations behind the belief, the basis is the movement of the planets along the band of stars we know as the Zodiac.

Astronomy

Astronomy does not underline the existence nor does it recognize Astrology as anything but superstition. Astronomy focuses on the scientific study and mathematical calculations of everything above and below us. Astronomy is based on scientific evidence. Though there are many unexplained theories, they are mostly based on educated guesses originating from earlier observations and calculations.

Zodiac

The band of stars centered around the ecliptic, the area through which the sun appears to move. Appears to move, as the Earth is actually rotating around the sun. This movement and path, creates the illusion that the sun is doing the movement.

Astrology and Astronomy differences.

As pointed out the first is seen as superstition, the second as science. Astrology used 12 star signs to divide the zodiac and Astronomy used 13 signs. The constellation of Ophiuchus, the Serpent Bearer is a stretch of sky through which the planets and Sun seem to move. The fact that the year only has 12 months could have influenced the decision to leave out Ophiuchus.

In Conclusion

The predictions made by Astrologers are sometimes mind boggling correct, yet you will not find an astronomer that takes Astrology seriously. The contrary is my personal observation. You hardly find an Astrologer able to show you the planets in the sky. The vast distances in space make the influence of the planets on any living human a very debatable subject.

UmeedAstrology
October 18, 2009, 01:11 PM
I don't think Astrology is superstitious but yes its differs from astronomy because astronomy involves study of position of planets etc and astrology is the study of effects of those changes on human life.

Thanks.

AstroGuru
October 19, 2009, 04:26 PM
Your article is short of many facts.Just to say "astrology originated from babylon" is complete false and undermines the rich historical facts about India.

Indian Astrology originated from Vedic Scriptures, dating back at least ten to twenty thousand years before western astrology. And the Vedas are the oldest books of the world library. They are the world’s most ancient scriptures and the most vast, complete system of knowledge known to man.

AstroGuru