Half Blood Prince [Archive]

ashi rocks

December 21, 2005, 09:20 PM

natasha

December 22, 2005, 08:43 AM

hey ..
the romance was very cute especially between ron and hermoine.......
and i think that snape is a member of the order ....
and maybe dumbledore is still alive ,maybe he has a horcrux too......

towhid

December 23, 2005, 06:16 AM

I don't think so Natasha. I think in the 7th book there will be some1 else who'll help Harry to finish you know who. And Dumbledore is dead. He didn't make any Horcrux i guess

natasha

December 23, 2005, 12:46 PM

you never know....cause killing you know who is not very easy.......
i dont know ,but i have the feeling that dumbledore isnt dead.......

towhid

December 24, 2005, 08:46 AM

Ok! whatever. May be u r right or may b i'm right or may b both r wrong. Coz u know Harry Potter isn't as easy as Hindi Serials. It's really tough. Except J.K Rowling No one can guess what's going to happen. But I have this feeling that Harry Potter is not going to end in the 7th Book. I mean He can't kill you know who in the 7th Book. I guess it'll take another 2 or 3 books. I also wish so. Coz I don't want Harry Potter to b finished so early

preetdazzles

December 24, 2005, 10:22 AM

hey ppl
where do u thinbk the horcruxes might be

ashi rocks

December 24, 2005, 03:33 PM

hey ppl
where do u thinbk the horcruxes might be

Hmmmmm.......theories theories....millions of little theories popping about in my head!:D Nice question!

Well, I don't know about all the Horcruxes but I think 2 can be accounted for, ignoring the 2 which have already been destroyed.

1) Well, the locket Horcrux which Harry and Dumbledore set out to find in HBP, there's a popular theory everywhere that R.A.B is Regulus A Black and that he hid the Horcrux in 12 Grimmauld place. And there's a mention of a heavy locket in Order of the Pheonix, In the chapter "The Noble and most ancient House of Black", on page no. 108. Its in the middle of the page, look for it.

2) Dumbledore suggested in HBP that Nagini might be a Horcrux too......but to find her...well...she's always with Voldemort, ain't she?

guddi

December 24, 2005, 10:38 PM

:p hermine and ron[FONT="Comic Sans MS"ashi rocks]Discuss everything here on the latest HP book on the block.

1. Do you think Snape's a Death-Eater or a member of the Order?

2. Is Dumbledore still alive?

3. How will Harry EVER find all those Horcruxes without Dumbledore's help?

4. What did you think of all the romance in the 6th book? (I loved it BTW)

5. Has your opinion of Malfoy changed after HBP?

Hi! ashi rocks,:cool:
I have read the latest book HBP. In this book i read that Albus Dumbledore dies. Yes, i think Snape's a Death-Eater or the member of the Order or You-Know-Who. He will find out those Horcruxes. I loved it very much. It was cool.
No.The movie was supper dupper hit. I loved very much. It was fantastic. I would be happy to all the remaining three parts.

Love from.
guddi.:cool: :rolleyes:

muackz

December 26, 2005, 01:41 PM

oh my god!!! U all have such gud theories.

i dnt think dumbldore dies. I think it will be like Gandalf from Lord of the Rings. Dumbldore will return and he will be more powerful. And i think that Harry wnt kill Voldemort alone. Ron and Hermoine are bound to help him. But i think Neville will help him to as harry and he share the same b'day and according to the prophecy they are both special. And i think snape is in the order and had to fake it to be a secret spy again!!!
muackz

hariputtar

December 26, 2005, 03:04 PM

I think dumbledore has faked his death, to make Voldemort lower his guards.
He will come back in next book, else it would be difficult for harry to distroy Voldemort.

ashi rocks

December 28, 2005, 06:33 PM

I think dumbledore has faked his death, to make Voldemort lower his guards.
He will come back in next book, else it would be difficult for harry to distroy Voldemort.

Yeah well, I hope Dumbledore is alive too! Without him, how an Harry destroy the Horcruxes and Voldemort?

muackz

January 3, 2006, 01:08 PM

ok!!! so i think dumbldore cnt die but i guess harry will wrk alone to destroy Voldemort!!! Ginny will help!!

And the horcruxe will be voldy's wand. Harry will destroy his wand to stop the other wand frm working (They are brother wands!!!) Malfoy will join harry as voldy will kill his mum and his dad's in Azkaban!
that's all for now!

muackz

sritee bharti

January 5, 2006, 11:36 AM

nah:mad: i dont think so. dunbledore has really died.:( d story is now on d journey of d trio.
SRITEE

sritee bharti

January 5, 2006, 11:41 AM

d last horcrux is harry(dat is his scar):p d night he killed lily n james,he transferred a bit of himself(his soul)in harry:eek: . N therefore in d end harry has 2 die.

ashi rocks

January 12, 2006, 01:40 AM

d last horcrux is harry(dat is his scar):p d night he killed lily n james,he transferred a bit of himself(his soul)in harry:eek: . N therefore in d end harry has 2 die.

Well, that's a good theory, but the Horcrux has to be an object not a scar. I don't think Harry will die!

iluvdan

January 21, 2006, 12:21 PM

http://www.GlitterMaker.com/created/19074659.gif (http://www.GlitterMaker.com/)

QUOTE=ashi rocks]Discuss everything here on the latest HP book on the block.

1. Do you think Snape's a Death-Eater or a member of the Order?

2. Is Dumbledore still alive?

3. How will Harry EVER find all those Horcruxes without Dumbledore's help?

4. What did you think of all the romance in the 6th book? (I loved it BTW)

5. Has your opinion of Malfoy changed after HBP?[/QUOTE]

hii everybody ..dis is natashu n after reading hbp dese r my views
i dont think snape is a death eater ..afterall dumldore trusts him sooooo much..n ddl is (or mayb was)1 of d cleverset wizards of all times..
didn he say dat he is gifted by exceptional mind...he won b fooled by a slimy oily git:D

ddl is aliv or not..v can only guess ..up2 jkrowlings mind ..but i think he mayb still alive u know ..my bro had this stupid theory dat d death eater who had died in d battle was morphed in2 ddl n d real ddl went in2 hiding 2 keep voldy in2 fake trust...vell its wierd theory but avada kedavra curse doesn make anybody fly ..does it..n when ddl is hit withit he flys off d tower...

i think if ddl is dead den mayb hell get some1 elses help ..ron n hermy r dere 4 him..mayb rufus scrimgour(dont laugh..v can make wild guesses 2)was so intersested in vere ddl goes..mayb he knows something...mayb slughorn wud help coz it was his fault...

d romance was too romantic..ha ha ..loved it esp of ron n hermy..was totally gaaa gaaa gaaa...rharry n ginny were gud 2 but 4 a very short time..

no malfoy is d same silly git showoff stupid idiot badmouthed wicked nblah blah...but mayb in d hbp he is shown more human in d last few chap

overall it was 1 of d best hp books
hey ask some more ques ..i like hp disc
luv natashu

http://www.GlitterMaker.com/created/19952515.gif (http://www.GlitterMaker.com/)

iluvdan

January 26, 2006, 06:04 PM

Dumbledore might not be dead. Did you notice when Snape said Avada Kedavra, Dumbledore's body flew off the tower? In the other books, when Voldy killed Frank Bryce, that Frank just dropped dead. When Wormtail killed Cedric, Cedric just fell to the ground. Just before Snape 'killed' Dumbledore, Dumbledore said "Severus..... Please". Dumbledore might have been trying to say "Severus..... Please.... Kill me". I will explain that now:

In the HBP, Hagrid heard Dumbledore and Snape arguing. "You agreed to do it Severus" and yada yada. Dumbledore was meaning that he wanted Snape to 'kill' him. On the tower, Snape said "Avada Kevavra". He might have said those words, but did he mean it? Remember at the end of OOTP, Bellatrix said to Harry when Harry tried the curse, "You have to mean it boy". Snape probably didn't mean it. Or that Snape said the words but said different words in his mind. The whole book of HBP was based on non-verbal spells. Dumbledore flew off the tower and down to the bottom, he might of been badly hurt.

After Dumbledore died and everyone was in the hospital wing, Fawkes sung that song. He might have been curing Dumbledore. What happened to Dumbledores body? When it was Dumbledores funeral, Hagrid brought Dumbledores body over to the coffin. Nobody could see the body because it was under a blanket. It might of been Fawkes. When 'Dumbledore' was in the coffin, the coffin exploded into flames without anyone doing it. The smoke comming from the fire had something flying through it. It was Fawkes. After Fawkes was away from the coffin, the coffin was instantly put out. The song Faekes sung might of been a death for himself song.

In chapter 2 (HBP), Snape was talking to Narcissa about Draco's mission. But, they never said what Draco had to do. And then they made the unbreakable vow. What if Snape was agreeing to help Draco to fix the vanishing cabinet. Which Draco did all by himself, so Snape was off the hook. And when Harry preformed Sectrusempra (I think that is it) on Draco, Snape wanted to see Harrys books. Harry brought Ron's potions book with him. Snape just let Harry off with a dozen dettentions. Snape probably had to remind hiself what side he was on. Snape might be a good guy.

Reply to this and tell me what you think

kashish_01

January 26, 2006, 10:45 PM

Yeah when dumbledore was saying severus please maybe snape and dumbledore were reading each others mind and dumbledore was reminding snape about his vow thats when his "wrinkles of hatred and revulsion showed up on his face". So snape might have done all this ON DUMBLEDORES orders.
Harry is definitely one of Tom Riddle's horcruxes, that's where the scar comes from. It explains how he got the ability to talk to snakes ( because Riddle could) and how he could feel Riddle's emotions and sense his thoughts. It also explains why he was drawn to the wand that is tied to Riddle's. Whether he has to die for Riddle to be killed remains to be seen. Perhaps the scar just needs to be magically removed.

Snape is not a traitor, he and Dumbledore worked out his killing Dumbledore in advance, so Snape could gain absolute trust with Riddle, while saving Draco from becoming a murderer.

Dumbledore is already alive again. Look at the bottom of page 645.
"Bright, white flames had erupted around Dumbledore's body and the tabler upon which they lay: Higher and higher they rose, obscuring the body. White smoke spiraled into the air and made strange shapes: Harry thought, for one heart-stopping moment, that he saw a phoenix fly joyfully into the blue, but next second the fire had vanished. In its place was a white marble tomb, encasing Dumbledore's body and the table on which he had rested."

In mythology, the Phoenix is the symbol of rebirth. Whenever one got old, it exploded into flames and recreated itself. Fawkes has done that for Dumbledore, so he can look for the remaining Horcruxes without anybody looking for him. That's why the body has to be hidden, first by flames, then by the tomb, and that's why the phoenix is flying JOYFULLY. Don't be surprised if Dumbledore is much youger the next time he appears.

AND YEAH harry is going to get dumbledores help even if he is dead remember the potrait in "mcgonagalls new office" well they might talk through there.

Some rumours I've heard:
From what I heard on the day Half blood prince came out was that in her speech she made at Edinburgh she said shes going to take a 4 YEAR rest and then start it.

Here are some rumours about the last book:
The final duel between Harry and Voldemort can't reside on wand power, as the wands can't fight one against the other. Could this mean that there will be some other way of combat, or could there be some complication with spells being reversed? Or will they fight with their minds?

The final word of the book is "scar"

We can expect these also to happen before the end of the series:
Snape to be redeemed.
One of the Gryffindors will become a Hogwarts teacher. It is rumoured this will be Neville?
Hermione will be Head Girl (quite obviously). Can we expect her to die on duty defending Gryffindor?
Lupin returns triumphantly, as a new legislation for semi-humans passes from the Ministry of Magic now that Umbridge is gone

R.A.B is Regulus Alphred Blac (Sirius Blacks bro)
Also the necklace ( Slytherin horcrux) is In order of pheonix In Blacks house it says on a page that There was a black heavy necklace that no-one could open. Could that be the horcrux?

ksluvs_1408

February 22, 2006, 12:13 PM

:) Hey people you all are forgetting one thing when all of us got to know that sirius is dead in the book five i heard some people saying that he is not dead or he has faked his own death.But See he died he did'nt returned back he did'nt came back also as a ghoust JKR destroyed all the posibilities of sirius coming back.So,I think Dumbledore is dead and I can bet it with anyone that he won't come back.:( .As for Harry Killing Voldemort I think that R.A.B guy will help him if he is not dead.I don't think that R.A.B is Regulus Black coz he did'nt had the guts to face Voldemort and his parents always taught him that Voldemort was on right track.I think Hagrid,Lupin,Peter Pettigrew&Some one from the Weasley Family would die and ofcource Snape will also die.I think Voldemort will also be killed as Harry will find all the horcruxes.I think Voldemort must have found something of Gryffindor or Ravenclaw and I think he would have hidden one of his horcrux in Riddle House or may be somewhere in Hogwarts or may be ha gave one of it to Snape to hide it and I also think that Harry will also be able to kill Nagini as she not always remain with Voldemort.

iluvdan

February 22, 2006, 01:46 PM

ya lets just accept it dat ddl is dead....:(
n as 4 snape.....let jk do d thinking...;)
luv natashu

seldon_iitkgp

March 3, 2006, 02:47 AM

my fav topic. is snape a death eater? is ddl dead?
plz discuss it guys. ive heard a million theories. hats off to jkr.
the way she has covered every angle is godlike.
2 gud. :)

Mac rocks_92

March 3, 2006, 03:19 PM

:rolleyes: Hey natasha I cannot accept that a powerful wizard like Dumbledore can die so easily. Besides he may be doing this as in the 7 book the story's to end and so maybe by pressuming himself to be dead he maybe trying to bring the Drk lord in limelight and then get killed by Harry.
We have seen in Ekta's serials How mihir and Jatin returned after death. Maybe Rowling just got inspired by them and We'll see dumbledore returning Achanak 36 saal baad. And i THINK the horcruxes are behind a bush, U know jhari ke piche in a plastic like the body parts in CID.:confused:

princess_ankita

March 3, 2006, 04:10 PM

i believe harry is a horcrux himself and only dumbledorre knows this secret so he has planned something for harry's protection and voldy's demise. cant wait for the answers to b revealed in the last book1

iluvdan

March 3, 2006, 05:22 PM

well....jitna zyaada disc karte hain utne zyadaa mere views badalte hain...
well i think ddl is DEAD:( ...just accept it yaar...kuynki dey had put up his potrait in princis office...dey wudnt have dun it if he was alive.....

n as 4 snape death eater...i dont noe:rolleyes:

natasha

March 3, 2006, 05:59 PM

Jk is not Ek so i definitely dont agree to the theory of ddl coming back ........

and if we agree to the fact that ddl is dead then snape has to be a death eater right?
he did use the most powerful and the killing curse, i dont think he was pretending.......

iluvdan

March 3, 2006, 06:04 PM

princess_ankita

March 10, 2006, 05:31 PM

even i think ddl is dead. maybe he knew wat was coming and has left some clues for harry which he'll find out soon. so many secrets to b revealed. the 7th book has high expectations frm me!

iluvdan

March 10, 2006, 07:55 PM

even i think ddl is dead. maybe he knew wat was coming and has left some clues for harry which he'll find out soon. so many secrets to b revealed. the 7th book has high expectations frm me!
yup dats true...

towhid

March 11, 2006, 10:20 AM

iluvdan

March 11, 2006, 06:48 PM

OMG! u brought Ekta in it. Why?? Rowling is not going to follow Ekta's path. So I also guess that Dumbledore is dead and I've a feelings that Harry himself is a horcrux. And dumbledore has planned sumthing for Harry obviously.

But u know wot u can think it in different way also. As b4 death Dumbledore told Snape that plzz do it Severus plzz. So i've a doubt if snape is really with You Know who or Dumbledore. But whenever I see Alan i feel that he is a bad guy:(

hey buddy v wer just thoinking ki ddl kaheen death se zindaa to nahi ho jayega... u noe dats d thing kekta does...proper cremation ke baad bhi aadmi zindaa ho jaate hain...:p ..
anyways...alan seems ok 2 me....

towhid

March 12, 2006, 06:38 AM

hey buddy v wer just thoinking ki ddl kaheen death se zindaa to nahi ho jayega... u noe dats d thing kekta does...proper cremation ke baad bhi aadmi zindaa ho jaate hain...:p ..
anyways...alan seems ok 2 me....
I know it but yeh toh jaroori nahin hain naa k rowling bhi wohi kare jo ekta kar rahin hain. Aur shaid Rowling ko pata bhi nahin ke there is a fictional serial maker named Ekta in India. :D Anyways Alan seems perfect villain to me. :(

iluvdan

March 12, 2006, 01:47 PM

ummm ya alan seems perfect..(no he IS perfect)4 villianous role....but i think he luks odd in dis pic...chak it out...

doesnt he luk oddly OLD??????:confused: :D

towhid

March 12, 2006, 09:01 PM

ummm ya alan seems perfect..(no he IS perfect)4 villianous role....but i think he luks odd in dis pic...chak it out...

doesnt he luk oddly OLD??????:confused:

Yeah! he is looking so old!!! HOw???:confused: In the movie he doesn't look that much old:( Anyways who cares abt snape;)

luna

March 13, 2006, 02:34 PM

well snape is sposed 2 be around 36 in Goblet (in the buks )

iluvdan

March 13, 2006, 02:55 PM

Yeah! he is looking so old!!! HOw???:confused: In the movie he doesn't look that much old:( Anyways who cares abt snape;)

ya hes iz luking old....i got that pic from sme function....

luv_life54

March 19, 2006, 12:33 PM

:cool: well all of us have different theories but i think that snape is from dumbledore's side and if he did kill ddl it was on his orders only.
but as for ddl being alive or not can't be said if he is alive then he did want to trick voldemort and let some of his defences fall and even if he is dead he really must have in some way planned to help harry. maybe snape will help harry in the end. who knows as jk rowling can anytime change.
i really am looking forward for the release of the seventh book. i hope it is soon.:p ;)

iluvdan

April 17, 2006, 05:18 PM

hey i dunno if anybody noticed dis...but do u guys remember dat harry first thinks dat hbp is his dad james....n lupin denies dat n tells him 2 check d date of d buk...
n wen harry checks it says sme year vich is 50 yrs ago...n he thinks ki my dad wasnt at dat time....
but dat means dat snape bhi nahi ho sakta...u noe snape n james were 2gether...
so it brings me back 2 hus buk is it????????????????

i think mayb snape 2 chanced on dat buk...mayb he didnt rite anything n pblly sme1 else rote all dat.....

dat brings me 2 1 more conclusion....as per d 2nd buk tom yani voldy was at hoggy nearly 50 yrs ago........plus he was a half blood..n young so prince...baad mein lord.....mayb its connected.....

hu noes....jk can change at d last mo.....but i had dese thoughts..n so posted dese here.............

latix

April 17, 2006, 06:15 PM

That's a good line of thought Natashu.I kinda agree with that theory.But it may be possible that the book always belonged
to Snape and he just switched covers the way Harry did to make his new book look old.

It may be that the cover was 50 years old but the Half Blood Prince is Snape and he wrote that on the cover after making the switch.
He like Harry may be no good at portions but became thanks to the book the way Harry did.So theories theories......sigh
Just a few more months away and by 2007 we may have the whole Harry Potter series on our book shelf.Uske baad forum ka kya hoga????

iluvdan

April 18, 2006, 03:13 PM

arre why wud he delibrately make his buk luk old??????????????????

n uske baad ye forum aur bhi sufi ho jayega!!!;)

latix

April 20, 2006, 06:29 PM

For the same reason that Harry did.I mean what if Snape has not made those notes and its been made by someone else.Snape was using
the book for the same reason Harry was.You know history repeats itself so many times in the series.

Harry and Ron become like Sirius and James,Harry likes a red head and so did James:D James was in gryffindor and so is Harry.
Hermione and Lily are pretty similar to eachother...Charlie was a good seeker and so is Ginny

iluvdan

April 21, 2006, 08:20 AM

yeah..but dats wat im saying...mayb its not snape's buk at all....
remember d memory in wich snape is crying in a corner while his parents r fighting......mayb dey cudnt afford buks....n he got a 2nd hand buk...
u noe..n all dose charms etc were not ritten by him...mayb he is not at all d half blood prince...

latix

April 21, 2006, 06:12 PM

Ya,I guess I agree with you.Snape may be bad,but not so bad that he'll invent spells to make someone bleed to death.

You know I personally have a feeling that Snape is not a faithful death eater.I trust that theory coz Dumbledore trusted Snape,and it will not be without reason.Also Snape is good at heart.
If it were not so,why would he try to save Harry in his first year.You may say that it was because James saved him,but
to think in that manner one needs to be good at heart.Dumbledore taught Voldemort all Voldy knows,but he still wanted to
kill him.Voldy does not have a heart

iluvdan

April 22, 2006, 11:15 PM

yeah dat loser hasnt got any soul..dil kya cheez hai...nah butter hai:p

it all depends upon jkr.....kya pata kab mud jaye........

luna

May 3, 2006, 08:26 PM

snape is ... well i cant figure him out ... maybe whateva we hav read about snape in HBP is for real ... u knw ... whateva he told cissy and bella mite be the truth ...
isnt it possible that we are soo used to jkr's ... um ... "trickery" and tact of keeping the story unpredictable that even this time we are expecting some big , shocking backstory about snape even though there mite nothing at all ???

but i like it unpredictable ;) .. i hope rowling "shocks" us again :D

iluvdan

May 3, 2006, 08:31 PM

hey dats true luna...but u noe i still have sme shak...howcum he owns a 50 yr old buk????????????????

it juzz doesnt fit dat he wud buy a 50 yr old buk...so it mayb passed on...u noe..
but u r true...v r khud serching 4 sme trciks..mayb dis tym v wont find any......

cum soon yaar..[am calling d 7th buk..not u bloke!:p ]

luna

May 6, 2006, 07:03 PM

rajinishivaram

June 6, 2006, 06:35 PM

hey ..
the romance was very cute especially between ron and hermoine.......
and i think that snape is a member of the order ....
and maybe dumbledore is still alive ,maybe he has a horcrux too......

Guyz,

I dont think JK should be concentrating on romance and stuff like that.Potter'sbecoming more hotter and she must concentrate on the main story set up.If she neglects this I dont think everything can be covered.Romance is fine but there r other things to think about

RAJINI

ashi rocks

June 6, 2006, 10:40 PM

I don't agree..... I think that the 7th book should be a balance of romance with the main plot and i think thts how its gonna be.

bcoz the main couples: harry/ginny n ron/hermione ARE important to the main plot.

like, voldey could try to harm ginny to hurt harry, or he could try to interfere b/w ron n hermione.

anyways, i think that JKR will finally show ron n hermine getting together atleast! bcoz, book6 was supposed 2 be a comedy of errors for ron n hermione as a couple as they tried making each other jealous and at the end of the book we see that they are past tht "jealous" stage and I think their relationship should be highlighted in book 7 against the backgrnd of war.

same goes with da harry/ginny story! JKR herself hinted tht ginny's gonna be an important character in book7 n also she is the only one except harry who directly was in contact with voldey

whaddaya think?:D

just my 2 knuts!:p

latix

June 7, 2006, 05:55 PM

Considering that Voldy has already harmed Ginny once just for being Harry's best friend's sister,I think that the order's biggest priority will be keeping Harry and Ginny out of harm's way.So harming Ginny will be tough and Voldy won't gain anything by harming Hermione.I mean he won't dirty his name by killing mudbloods(sorry for using the word but we are talking from Voldy's point of view right now)

rajinishivaram

June 7, 2006, 06:13 PM

Discuss everything here on the latest HP book on the block.

1. Do you think Snape's a Death-Eater or a member of the Order?

2. Is Dumbledore still alive?

3. How will Harry EVER find all those Horcruxes without Dumbledore's help?

4. What did you think of all the romance in the 6th book? (I loved it BTW)

5. Has your opinion of Malfoy changed after HBP?

Hey Guyz,

I think that Snape is a member of the Order.Remember he is an Occlumens.He can hide his thoughts fromthe Dark Lord.Of course there wouldnt be any meaning if Dumbledores alive.He ha given all the infi he could provide.Isnt it?I think Harry will have to take someones help?Now we will have to wait for the book to know?May be its Snape?The romance is good,especially the LOVE POTION when Ron goes behind Lavender.Actually speaking about Malfoy, he really doesnt want to indulge in such things.When Dumbledore told him to kill him he never did so.It is out of fear that he is working for VOLDEMORT.

Rajini:)

Nerd

June 18, 2006, 05:11 PM

Well i agree with the above post...but i personally have got less respect for Malfoy...If you are going to do something then you should do it to your best ability...i think this as Malfoy is one of my favourite characters,, but imagine how good it would been if he did carry out would Voldamort asked him to do........