PDA

View Full Version : are indian umpires no good?


gskumar
May 31, 2006, 06:35 PM
recently the upgraded elite panel of international umpires does not have even one indian umpire, are indian umpires really no good? i strongly feel they have been victimized by some strong recommendations from higher up. jayaprakash & hariharan are quite good umpires at the international level.

tommcat
June 8, 2006, 05:20 PM
I doubt Indian Umpires are being victimized, India already favours from majority of ICC decisions. Its time the BCCI takes things into notice & start programmes to improvize the umpiring standards in the country & bring out better umpires.

shrek
June 9, 2006, 10:19 PM
you cant say that, it is really double standards by the icc. hariharan & jayprakash arent new to the scene and have a proven record. they are far better compared to the earlier bunch of elite panel clowns.

the icc needs to be more transparent in letting out the indians know on what scales umpires were selected and what negatives the indians had.